• Home
  • Graham Davey's Blog
  • My Books
    • Published Books
    • New Book Projects >
      • Psychopathology 3e Excerpts
  • My Research
  • The Sidcup Mixer
  • Journals
  • News
    • Latest News
    • Clinical Psychology Research & Chat
  • Real Life
Papers from Sidcup
Graham Davey's website

The Funding of Mental Health Research in the UK – A Biased and Flawed System?

6/22/2015

 
Picture
Where do you look in the UK for research funding for psychological approaches to understanding mental health problems? If you trained as a psychologist or have a psychology degree, you will be well aware of the valuable contribution that psychological models can make to an understanding of mental health. You will also realize that psychology offers a broader approach than basic biological models to understanding the cognitive and social factors that contribute to mental health problems.

So how do research psychologists with an interest in mental health get their hands on funding for psychological approaches and models? Only with great difficulty it seems!

Over the past decade or more, I’ve been hearing more and more stories from researchers of how psychologically-oriented research is being blatantly squeezed out of the funding picture in favour of basic biological research. In this post I’m focusing on what the current picture looks like in the UK, but I know that many experimental psychopathologists in other parts of Europe are experiencing similar funding biases towards biological models – even to the point where the medics and biologists on many funding panels don’t know what a psychological model is - let alone know how to evaluate one!

Lets look at the current funding situation for mental heath research in the UK. Two of the largest funders that explicitly advertise funding for mental health problems are the Medical Research Council (MRC) and the Wellcome Trust.

The Neuroscience & Mental Health Funding Panel of the MRC claim:

 “We fund innovative research that tells us how the brain controls our behaviour, how the nervous system functions throughout life in health and disease and how it responds to injury. We also support the development of tools and techniques that help others carry out research on the nervous system. We are particularly interested in multidisciplinary research that will increase our understanding of the brain in health and disease.”
The mental health research that we fund includes clinical, developmental, genetic and neuropharmacological aspects of poor mental health and the pathways to mental illness and wellbeing.”

Not much scope for psychological models there then! There is the mention of ‘clinical’ aspects of poor mental health, but I suspect that is a direct reference to the general sense of the term ‘clinical’ in relating to the treatment of actual patients rather than to the approaches typical of clinical psychology. Why do I think this? Because currently the Neuroscience & Mental Health Funding Panel has 23 members of which NOT ONE is either a clinical psychologist or an expert in experimental psychopathology.

Now let’s look at the Wellcome Trust “Cognitive Neuroscience & Mental Health Expert Review Group”. The claim here is that:

‘This Expert Review Group will consider requests for support to improve understanding of how the brain functions at the cognitive level, and to find improved approaches for treating brain and mental health disorders. Its remit includes:
•          Systems-based research including cognition and behavioural neuroscience
•          Neurological disorders
•          Mental health disorders
•          Translational neuroscience, including cognitive interventions
Genetics with detailed clinical phenotypic assessments.”

Its remit does include ‘mental health disorders’ and it regularly mentions ‘cognition’ as a suitable topic for research. However, I suspect it’s not expecting many grant applications from psychologists, because of the 9 current members of this expert review group, only one is a clinical psychologist.

I don’t have any figures to support this claim, but I suspect that the number of experimental psychopathology or clinical psychology applications submitted to both MRC and the Wellcome Trust has declined significantly over the past 10-15 years, but from the staffing of their review panels, it seems clear that these two organizations are not encouraging submissions based on psychological approaches nor currently do they have the expertise to effectively evaluate them if they do receive any.

In response to the obvious biological and medical remit of the MRC and the Wellcome Trust, many psychological researchers investigating mental health issues have turned to the Economic & Social Research Council (ESRC) for funding. For the ESRC, mental health falls under the “Health & Wellbeing” Research Topic – but this Research Topic does not simply specialize in funding psychological models of mental health, but the funding of mental health research across the disciplines of economics, social policy, politics, human geography, legal studies, criminology, demography, and education to name but a few.

If you’re a clinical psychologist or an experimental psychopathologist your research would fall under Panel A, and so you would have to compete for funding with Economists, Management & Business Studies, and Statistics, Computing & Methodologies. Panel A has 16 members of which 6 are currently psychologists – but none are clinical psychologists or experts in mental health research per se.

Another general source of funding for mental health researchers is the National Institute for Health Research (NIHR).  But if you are a clinical psychologist then your chances of success seem to be limited if you are competing with all other medical and health professionals for funding. For example, NIHR funds research fellowships at five levels from doctoral to senior and transitional research level. The 5 panels that assess applications consist of a total of 74 members – of which just 1 is a clinical psychologist! The February 2015 figures show that out of 380 current personal awards from NIHR, only 7 have gone to clinical psychologists, and only 42 of these awards have gone to mental health researchers in general.

So why does all this matter?

·      There is a large and growing bias in UK mental health research funding towards biological and medical models, and away from psychological approaches and models. This discriminates against the valuable contribution made to an understanding of mental health problems by psychological models. 

·      Even if psychological researchers do attempt to apply for funds from the main mental health research funders, their panels do not appear to be populated with experts capable of properly evaluating psychological submissions. 

·      The relentless focus of funding bodies on biological and medical models of mental distress do not match the priorities of service user groups, many of whom express a very clear desire for alternatives to medication, they support models that reflect the social model of disability, and favour better person-centred support (e.g. the National Survivor User Network).

This is becoming an urgent matter, and it would seem to be an issue that needs to be addressed by the professional bodies representing both psychological researchers in general and clinical psychologists in particular. We also need to remember that psychology’s contribution to mental health is not simply at the level of the development of effective psychological interventions, but also at the level of developing etiological models of mental health problems based on psychological processes. The current paucity of funding outlets for psychological approaches has already made these approaches wrongly appear to be ‘second class’ in comparison with biological and medical models. That unjustified imbalance needs to be fully repaired.

http://awriter.org/ link
8/24/2015 05:46:29 pm

Exquisitely professional thoughts. I merely hit upon this web site and desired to enunciate that I've definitely delighted in reckoning your blog articles or blog posts. Rest assured I'll subsist pledging to your RSS and I wish you write-up after much more shortly

psd to responsive html link
1/29/2018 06:18:52 am

Hey There. I found your blog using msn. This is a very well written article. I’ll be sure to bookmark it and come back to read more of your useful info. Thanks for the post. I’ll definitely return.

Kilian link
9/29/2015 12:07:19 pm

Well i guess this very deep thoughts

neurosurgery personal statement link
10/24/2015 09:03:33 am

We should support the development of tools and techniques that help others carry out research on the nervous system. We are particularly interested in multidisciplinary research that will increase our understanding of the brain in health and disease.

model rambut pria 2016 link
1/10/2016 01:14:03 am

oket thank for sharing

model rambut panjang untuk wanita link
1/10/2016 01:22:13 am

mental healt is very important

cara memakai hijab terbaru link
1/10/2016 01:26:41 am

thank for the sharing this is very important

http://proofreading-services.org/professional.php link
6/12/2016 07:49:11 am

This is very informative blog. i think this information can be very isefull for some people./

diabetic diet plan link
6/19/2016 02:52:56 am


So how do research psychologists with an interest in mental health get their hands on funding for psychological approaches and models? Only with great difficulty it seems!

custom essay writing link
9/20/2016 12:47:41 am

The research is really interesting. rhe scientists do the most interesting thing.

best cardio for stomach fat link
11/2/2016 10:33:46 pm

Thanks a lot for sharing us about this update. Hope you will not get tired on making posts as informative as this.

yoga for impotence link
12/6/2016 12:08:46 pm

Enhance your experience of yoga exercises and your own self by being attentive to how you exercise, when you exercise and why you exercise. Alternatives are transferred to each.

Nursing student blog link
1/23/2017 05:46:48 am

Contract cheating, roughly defined as where a students uses or pays a third party to produce assessed work on their behalf, is of concern across all academic disciplines and educational levels. Contract cheating in nursing, where students use essay mills and term paper mills, is of particular concern. This article discusses the growth of the problem and the associated implications for health care.

Camping site link
2/9/2017 01:24:28 am

The occupational health services provided by employers address the health promotion, health protection and health care needs of working population. They have been identified as an important component of the public health system. OH services can make a significant contribution to essential governmental initiatives, such as; increasing health equality, improving social cohesion, and reducing sickness absence. They help to reduce the overall burden of diseases worldwide.

mini gastric bypass Pittsburg KS link
2/18/2017 03:09:45 am

Even though you may see gastric bypass as a quick fix for a weighty problem, you must certainly consider the medical implications before you make the surgical commitment to bariatric surgery. For many individuals, especially those who have battled mightily for years with the excess weight, this intervention can be a life saving choice. But the important thing to remember is that gastric bypass surgery is certainly not without substantial, serious and lifelong medical implications. This decision must not be taken lightly.

bulk link
3/1/2017 11:48:01 pm

Very nice article, I enjoyed reading your post, very nice share, I want to twit this to my followers. Thanks!.

read more link
3/4/2017 06:22:49 am

Science is the field of answers but we get those only when we ask questions. Microbiology in particular is evolving with time and the microbiologists are helping the world with the questions it has about tiny living organisms. Before we come to Escherichia Coli, there are a few things that need our attention. So what exactly is molecular microbiology? We know that microbiology is a branch of science that deals with tiny living organisms, their nature and effect on the nature. Molecular microbiology is the field that studies about the molecular basis like metabolism, plant-bacteria interaction, gene regulation and all the microorganisms' physiological processes.

SHADED Co link
3/6/2017 01:03:57 am

If a patient has a health condition that would benefit from the use of cannabis, where would he or she find a list of medical marijuana doctors? Here are some guidelines for locating a physician.

Beard Care link
3/15/2017 04:15:00 am

Buy The Gentlemen's Beard Oil and Conditioner Softener on Amazon.com ✓ FREE SHIPPING on qualified orders.

Phentermine link
3/22/2017 07:17:00 am

Easy dieting and exercise may not work for everyone. If you're one of those individuals who need more assistance to lose weight, than a diet pill might be your best answer. There are lots of diet pills on the market to help reach your required goal. There are diet pills on the market that are safe, effective, cost-effective, and offer long-term benefits.

Canada MedLaser Clinic link
3/28/2017 12:28:12 pm

What constitutes a realistic cellulite body treatment? How can cellulite be eliminated? Find out in this article!

Addiction Rehab Toronto link
3/29/2017 02:03:20 pm

Drug addiction treatment has only one goal: to help addicts attain a life free of drug use. It achieves this goal in a variety of ways, but all of them are focused on helping addicts modify their existing destructive behaviors into healthier ones.

Bathmate Hydromax link
4/4/2017 05:17:56 am

Thousands of users are using penis pumps to get the result that this amazing device has to offer. No doubt this device has proven to be a boon for the men who suffered from the problem of erectile dysfunction. These men could get the benefit of these pumps because they knew about it, but there are many other men who are still apprehensive about using these pumps.

mesothelioma lawsuits link
4/4/2017 11:33:09 pm

Finding a mesothelioma attorney through directories may be helpful for initial screening. As far as choosing one is concerned, it comes to make your decisions based on hard facts of life that if you or one of your family member is the victim of mesothelioma, the attorney must have a proven track record of bringing justice to your already sullen situation; after all, an attorney is an attorney.

cosmetic surgery in Houston link
5/1/2017 05:35:09 am

Knowing all the pros and cons about cosmetic surgery is a must

Robert J Fink Chicago link
5/22/2017 08:37:42 am

Regardless of what type of hand surgery you may be going under, there are some questions you'll want answered before the procedure. Here are some essential questions to ask your doctor before undergoing hand surgery.

Health link
6/12/2017 11:06:26 am

Why does health care fraud appear to get the 'lions-share' of attention? Could health care fraud be the perfect vehicle for driving agendas of divergent groups? Take a closer look and one finds this is no game-of-chance, taxpayers, consumers and providers always lose.

Fitobalt link
6/15/2017 10:51:41 am

It is not enough to know about healthy food or exercise. It is not adequate to focus on your body and forget about other aspects. Health is about the combination of all important factors.

halotherapy at home link
6/25/2017 03:03:56 pm

The benefits of salt therapy (also called Halotherapy) or speleotherapy are well known and documented in Europe. This salt therapy being very well known for its beneficial effects, a Romanian inventor puts his mind at work and developed a device that is able to reproduce a speleotherapy micro environment in your home in an affordable and convenient way.

CBD Oil Wholesale link
7/20/2017 03:08:49 am

Looking to try CBD? Checkout globalgamenation.net.

innova primary care huntsville link
7/22/2017 05:38:17 am

Thanks for providing recent updates regarding the concern, I look forward to read more.

iv vitamin therapy kuta link
7/25/2017 01:27:17 am

In recent years an intravenous vitamin drip known as The Myers Cocktail has become the latest health craze, and for good reason. The Myers Cocktail, along with similar IV vitamin therapies, has been used successfully to treat many ailments, as an immune system booster and as part of a normal health regime. Developed in the 1970s by physician John Myers, M.

oregano oil link
7/25/2017 02:13:25 am

Wild Oregano oil was widely used thousands of years ago. Today its benefits are not so well known but becoming increasingly popular among herbalists and natural therapists. Here are listed 9 Oregano oil uses that could save you a trip to the drug store.

ob gyn phoenix az link
8/6/2017 10:55:14 am

It's important to do thorough research on the different types of healthcare careers currently available in the industry. At this point there are over 200 different job occupations to choose from, so you will probably want to study as much as possible in order to figure out exactly which of these jobs will suit you best.

Smoky Mountain Beard Products link
8/16/2017 02:09:40 pm

High quality, all natural beard care products, scented with 100% pure essential oils! Beard oil, beard balm, beard wash, beard combs and more!

best insect repellent australia link
8/22/2017 12:17:40 am

Every year, new so-called mosquito-repellent solutions appear on the market. All have similarities and differences, the similarity being that all of them are being purchased in huge amounts by consumers. The difference is that some work and some don't.

emf australia link
8/22/2017 12:30:46 am

Research shows a big relationship between EMF radiation and health. Electromagnetic fields are in almost all homes and offices, and too much can kill.

youtube to mp3 converter link
9/16/2017 05:01:10 am

Thank you for providing insight into various photography blogs. I will Definatly Bookmark this blog. I would request you to post more blogs as you write well and your post are useful.

upload to instagram from pc link
9/16/2017 05:27:59 am

Well thanks for posting such an outstanding idea. I like this blog & I like the topic and thinking of making it right.

instagram online viewer link
9/17/2017 03:43:18 am

Thanks a lot for sharing us about this update. Hope you will not get tired on making posts as informative as this

instagram online link
9/17/2017 04:09:51 am

I am very enjoyed for this blog. Its an informative topic. It help me very much to solve some problems. Its opportunity are so fantastic and working style so speedy.

invokana lawsuit link
11/11/2017 09:57:26 am

People were injured by the diabetes drug Invokana, many had to have their toes,feet, and legs amputated.We at Consumer Claims Center of America assist people that were injured by Invokana.

mochatonix link
11/15/2017 08:41:28 am

Find great deals for Mocaine - Chocolate Fat-burning Energy Mocha.

apetamin link
11/17/2017 08:09:19 am

This is a Good Reading post.

DClin trainee
12/2/2017 03:56:49 am

Thanks for this blog post - it was really useful and interesting. Do you have any references on this topic or perhaps looking at how researchers of psychological models have managed this (adhering in some way to a medical model in order to obtain funding perhaps)? Thanks!

Graham Davey
12/3/2017 01:01:42 am

Nothing immediately comes to mind - Richard Bentall has commented on this particular issue regularly on Twitter, and I've written an article on experimental psychopathology and how we valid psychological models of mental health problems here http://pr.textrum.com/index.php?art_id=62#.WiO9Z7acbUY

boosters link
12/20/2017 10:51:46 pm


This is a great inspiring article.I am pretty much pleased with your good work.You put really very helpful information. Keep it up. Keep blogging. Looking to reading your next post.

user review link
12/25/2017 11:49:01 pm


This blog is really great. The information here will surely be of some help to me. Thanks!.

acheter Cialis sans ordonnance link
1/25/2018 08:44:13 am

In the US and many other countries, a "generic" drug is a copy of a brand-name drug. It has identical active ingredients as the brand-name version, and so it is the same as the brand-name version in dosage, safety, strength, quality, performance, and intended use.

Buy Essay Online | bigpaperwriter.com link
4/3/2018 02:40:57 am

Well, I just wanted to thank you for all those efforts you have out in order to provide us with such a clearly-written article! Marvelous post!

keto diet weight loss link
1/14/2019 01:22:23 am

Great post, and great website. Thanks for the information!

downloadpopcorntimeapk.com link
2/5/2019 10:42:53 am

Youre so cool! I don’t suppose I’ve read anything like this before. So nice to find somebody with some original thoughts on this subject. really thank you for starting this up. this website is something that is needed on the web, someone with a little originality. useful job for bringing something new to the internet!

chiropractor near me link
2/12/2019 10:26:18 pm

Hey what a brilliant post I have come across and believe me I have been searching out for this similar kind of post for past a week and hardly came across this. Thank you very much and will look for more postings from you.

pikbee link
3/19/2019 03:30:23 am

Thanks for sharing your post, That's so nice and interesting

Flash Game basics link
4/3/2019 12:28:30 am

Hello! I just would like to give a huge thumbs up for the great info you have here on this post. I will be coming back to your blog for more soon.

토토사이트 link
4/12/2019 12:18:20 pm

Thanks for the blog loaded with so many information. Stopping by your blog helped me to get what I was looking for.

Kiurnir link
4/15/2020 10:19:00 pm

nice

Kaleb link
12/29/2020 05:52:20 pm

Thank you forr this

keonhacai link
9/4/2021 03:00:11 am

Thanks for some other excellent article. The place else may anybody get that type of info in such an ideal means of writing? I have a presentation next week, and I’m on the search for such information. <a href="http://keonhacai.wiki/">keonhacai</a>


Comments are closed.

    Author

    Graham C. L. Davey, Ph.D. is Professor of Psychology at the University of Sussex, UK. His research interests extend across mental health problems generally, and anxiety and worry specifically. Professor Davey has published over 140 articles in scientific and professional journals and written or edited 16 books including Psychopathology; Clinical Psychology; Applied Psychology; Complete Psychology; Worrying & Psychological Disorders; and Phobias: A Handbook of Theory, Research & Treatment. He has served as President of the British Psychological Society, and is currently Editor-in-Chief of Journal of Experimental Psychopathology and Psychopathology Review. When not writing about psychology he watches football and eats curries.

    Archives

    September 2019
    May 2019
    August 2018
    July 2018
    June 2015
    April 2015
    November 2014
    March 2014
    December 2013
    July 2013
    June 2013
    April 2013
    March 2013

    Categories

    All
    Anxiety
    Books
    Clinical Psychology
    Journal Publishing
    Medicine
    Mental Health
    Phobias
    Psychology
    Research
    Research Councils

    RSS Feed

Proudly powered by Weebly